Addiction is a choice

TL;DR: Addiction is not as involuntary as society often portrays. While biochemical factors play a role, the concept of addiction as a choice challenges deeply held beliefs about personal accountability and societal narratives.

Quick Nugget: Addiction isn’t a disease; it’s a decision shaped by values, environment, and, yes, willpower. What happens if we stop treating it like a terminal diagnosis?

A Provocative Exploration

Imagine standing at a crossroads. On one path lies a set of habits you know will harm you—substances, behaviors, or impulses that drain your vitality.

On the other lies a tougher, steeper road of resistance and self-control. What’s stopping you from choosing the latter?

The mainstream narrative around addiction is comforting in its simplicity. We’re told addiction is a disease, rooted in genetic predispositions and brain chemistry. And while these factors are real, they’re not destiny.

To call addiction a disease absolves individuals of accountability. What if we flipped the script and acknowledged that, at its core, addiction involves choice?

Years ago, I watched a close friend spiral into addiction. His vice was gambling—not substance abuse, but the allure of bright screens and quick wins.

He told me, "I can’t stop; it’s in my DNA." Yet, when he hit rock bottom, something shifted.

He made a choice to quit, not because his brain chemistry had miraculously changed but because he decided his future mattered more than fleeting gratification.

His story isn’t unique; it’s emblematic of how choice can rewrite narratives.

What the Science Really Says

Yes, addiction changes the brain. Neural pathways are rewired; dopamine systems are hijacked.

But does that mean addiction removes choice entirely?

Not quite.

Research shows that individuals can and do overcome addictions without professional intervention.

The phenomenon of "spontaneous remission," where people quit harmful behaviors without therapy or medication, underscores the power of agency.

Consider the Vietnam War veterans who returned home addicted to heroin. Studies found that 95% of them quit after leaving the war zone.

Why?

Their environment changed, and with it, their choices.

The Power of Values

Addiction thrives when values waver. If you value short-term pleasure over long-term growth, you’re more likely to succumb.

But when values shift—when health, relationships, or purpose take precedence—the grip of addiction weakens.

Choice, then, is about aligning actions with what truly matters.

Everyday Choices Reflect This

Think about your relationship with caffeine, social media, or food. Have you ever needed that morning coffee or doom-scrolled for hours?

These are mild forms of addiction, yet they’re manageable because you know you have a choice.

Apply the same logic to more severe addictions, and the principle remains: choice is central.

Data Doesn’t Lie—But Interpretation Matters

Self-Recovery Statistics: Studies from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism reveal that about 75% of people who overcome alcohol dependence do so without professional help.

Environment vs. Genetics: Research by Dr. Bruce Alexander’s "Rat Park" experiment showed that rats given enriched environments chose water over drug-laced alternatives. Environment profoundly influences behavior.

Cultural Variations: In cultures where certain substances are normalized but not demonized, addiction rates are often lower. This suggests societal narratives play a role.

Stories of people overcoming the odds—quitting cold turkey, resisting peer pressure, or transforming their lives—aren’t rare. They’re evidence of human resilience and decision-making.

Choice doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Access to resources, supportive relationships, and alternative coping mechanisms can tilt the scales toward better decisions. But even in their absence, individuals have proven capable of change.

So, where do we land? Addiction is complex. It’s shaped by biology, environment, and yes, choice.

But the narrative we choose matters.

When we frame addiction as a choice, we empower individuals to take control.

This perspective isn’t about blame; it’s about agency.

Do you believe addiction is a choice, a disease, or something in between? Hit reply and share your thoughts.

Contrarian Wisdom is a space for thinkers who dare to defy the ordinary, challenge conventional wisdom, and spark bold conversations to rethink deeply held beliefs.

Share this newsletter with someone who needs a reminder.