People judge you by appearances, whether they admit it or not

TL;DR: People judge you by appearances — Always. Whether it's your clothing, posture, or tone of voice, the world forms its first impressions in seconds. This may feel unfair, but understanding and leveraging this reality gives you an edge. Don’t fight it; work it to your advantage.

Quick Contrarian Nugget: Society tells you not to judge a book by its cover, but almost everyone does. Master the art of first impressions, and you'll rewrite how the world "reads" you.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Appearances

“People don’t judge books by their covers,” they say. A noble lie, but a lie nonetheless.

From the moment you walk into a room, the clock starts ticking.

Research shows it takes about 7 seconds for someone to form a first impression of you.

Seven seconds.

That’s faster than it takes to scan a menu at your favorite coffee shop.

Within this microscopic slice of time, people decide if you’re competent, trustworthy, attractive, or interesting.

Does that sound shallow? Of course.

Is it fair? Not even close.

Nonetheless, It’s universal. 

Whether it’s a prospective boss, a new friend, or a stranger on the subway, the human brain is wired to assess others quickly based on external cues.

The clothes you wear, the way you carry yourself, the expressions on your face — these are all “data points” feeding into someone’s snap judgment about you.

The question is, are you owning the narrative, or letting it own you?

You Are a Walking Brand

Imagine you’re at a networking event. Two people approach you:

• Person A is dressed sharply, exudes confidence, and speaks with clarity.

• Person B slouches, avoids eye contact, and looks like they just rolled out of bed.

Who do you instinctively gravitate toward? Be honest.

You might think Person B is equally capable, but your subconscious isn’t taking that gamble.

We like to think of ourselves as rational beings who prioritize substance over style. But psychology tells a different story.

Appearances act as a shortcut for the brain.

It doesn’t have time to unpack someone’s résumé or inner virtues in the first 30 seconds, so it takes the path of least resistance: judging the cover.

This isn’t limited to high-stakes scenarios. Think about:

• Job interviews: A polished outfit and strong handshake can outshine even a superior résumé.

• Dating apps: Profiles with professionally taken photos are consistently swiped right more often.

• Social media influencers: Why do you think so many invest in aesthetics, even when their content is average?

Why This Matters More Than Ever

We live in a hyper-visual age. In 2024, attention spans are microscopic, and first impressions often happen through screens before real-life interactions.

Your LinkedIn profile photo, your Instagram grid, or the way you present yourself in a Zoom call can make or break opportunities before you’ve uttered a single word.

But here’s where this gets interesting.

Controlling appearances doesn’t mean being fake.

It means being intentional. 

Crafting your external presentation to match your internal substance is not manipulation — it’s self-mastery.

Science Backs This Up

• Halo Effect: This cognitive bias means we assume that people who look good must be good. Studies show that attractive people are often perceived as smarter, kinder, and more competent, regardless of their actual qualifications.

• Posture and Confidence: Amy Cuddy’s famous TED Talk on “power poses” demonstrated how body language impacts both how others see you and how you feel about yourself.

• Clothing Matters: Research from Princeton found that people wearing tailored suits were rated as more competent than those in casual attire, even when performing the same tasks.

Relatable Examples

• The Job Applicant: A friend of mine recently lost out on a marketing role to someone with half their experience. Why? The winner walked into the interview dressed like they already had the job. My friend showed up in jeans and “startup casual.” The message? I’m not taking this seriously.

• The Grocery Store Test: Ever noticed how cashiers or strangers treat you differently based on what you’re wearing? Try going out in sweatpants one day and business casual the next. The contrast will be startling.

Isn’t This Superficial?

Yes, it’s superficial. And no, it’s not going away.

Fighting the reality of first impressions is like arguing against gravity. It’s a losing battle.

But there’s an upside.

Appearances are one of the few things you control.

You can’t change your height or bone structure, but you can upgrade your wardrobe, posture, and presence.

Rewrite Your First Impression

Let’s end with a challenge. Over the next week, try these three exercises:

1. Audit Your Appearance: Stand in front of a mirror. Look at your posture, grooming, and outfit. Ask yourself, Does this align with how I want to be perceived?

2. Master Non-Verbal Signals: Practice maintaining eye contact, offering a firm handshake, and walking with purpose. These small tweaks make a huge difference.

3. Experiment with Context: Dress slightly above the “norm” for one day — whether it’s at work, running errands, or meeting friends. Notice how people react.

This isn’t about vanity; it’s about empowerment. When you acknowledge how much appearances matter, you’re taking control of your narrative in a world that judges you before you even open your mouth.

So, the next time someone tells you, “Don’t worry about what others think,” they’re either lying or deluding themselves.

What others think doesn’t define you, but it does open or close doors.

Take charge of the story you’re telling before someone else writes it for you.

What do you think? How have appearances influenced your life, for better or worse? Hit reply and share your thoughts. I’d love to feature some of your responses in next week’s issue.

Honest Contrarian is a space for thinkers who dare to defy the ordinary, challenge conventional wisdom, and spark bold conversations to rethink deeply held beliefs.

Share this newsletter with someone who needs a reminder.