The tyranny of choice

TL;DR: More options don’t always mean better choices. In fact, too many choices can paralyze decision-making, sap happiness, and lead to dissatisfaction.

Quick Contrarian: The abundance of options in modern life isn’t a sign of freedom. It’s a silent form of oppression that leaves us stuck, second-guessing, and unfulfilled.

The Illusion of Freedom

Let me start with a question that might seem absurd. When was the last time you felt overwhelmed at the grocery store?

You’re standing in the cereal aisle, staring at dozens of brightly colored boxes, each promising a better breakfast experience than the last.

You pick one after five minutes of deliberation, but as you’re walking away, you start to wonder: Did I choose the right one? Was the other brand healthier, tastier, or better value?

And just like that, a mundane decision leaves you feeling oddly unsettled.

Now, multiply that by every choice you make in a day. What to wear. What to watch. What to eat. What career path to follow. Who to date.

The modern world — with its endless buffet of options — promises us freedom but often delivers anxiety.

The paradox of choice is that the more options we have, the harder it becomes to choose.

And when we do choose, we’re less satisfied with our decision because of the nagging feeling that we might’ve made a better one.

The marketing and tech industries will have you believe that choice is the ultimate power.

After all, who doesn’t want more control?

But here’s the uncomfortable truth: Too much choice isn’t empowering; it’s exhausting. And instead of giving us clarity, it creates confusion and regret.

The Science of Paralysis

Psychologists call this phenomenon choice overload or decision fatigue. Studies, like the famous jam experiment by Sheena Iyengar, reveal something fascinating.

When shoppers were presented with six varieties of jam, they were more likely to make a purchase than when presented with 24 options.

Why? Because too many options make decision-making feel like a chore rather than an opportunity.

Let me put it another way. Every decision you make depletes your mental energy.

Choosing between two things is manageable. Choosing between 20? That’s when your brain starts to short-circuit.

And what happens when you’re overwhelmed?

You either:

• Avoid making a decision altogether.

• Pick something at random and immediately regret it.

• Spend hours agonizing over the choice, leaving you drained and less productive for the rest of the day.

It’s not just minor choices like jam or cereal, either. This tyranny of choice extends to major life decisions.

Think about online dating. Swipe culture gives you access to endless potential partners, yet studies show that people feel less satisfied with their relationships because they can’t shake the idea that someone better might be one swipe away.

More Isn’t Always Better

Psychologist Barry Schwartz coined the term "the paradox of choice" to describe how having too many options can lead to paralysis and dissatisfaction.

Here’s the paradox in a nutshell:

• When you have only a few choices, your decision is straightforward. The stakes feel manageable.

• But when you’re faced with dozens (or hundreds) of options, decision-making becomes a high-stakes game. What if you choose wrong? What if there’s something better out there?

This dynamic plays out everywhere. Take these common examples:

• Streaming Services: You open Netflix, eager to relax, only to spend 45 minutes scrolling through endless titles and genres. By the time you finally settle on a movie, you’re too tired to enjoy it.

• Dating Apps: The promise of meeting "the one" is replaced by the anxiety of swiping through hundreds of profiles. Every match feels replaceable, and every decision feels incomplete.

• Career Paths: Your grandparents likely had a straightforward career trajectory: find a job, stick with it, retire. Today, the world tells you to “follow your passion,” which is inspiring until you’re drowning in options. Do you stick with a stable career or chase a startup dream? What if you pivoted into tech? Or real estate? Or opened a bakery? The possibilities are infinite…and exhausting.

• The Dinner Menu Dilemma: Imagine you’re out at a fancy restaurant. The waiter hands you a menu the size of a novella — page after page of appetizers, mains, specials, and desserts. You start reading, then rereading, then asking for recommendations. By the time you order, you’re exhausted. And here’s the kicker: No matter how good your dish is, you’ll wonder if you should’ve gone with something else.

These examples aren’t just anecdotal. Studies show that people presented with more options are less satisfied with their decisions. It’s called post-decision regret or buyer’s remorse, and it’s a hallmark of modern consumer culture.

The Freedom Myth

In theory, having more options should be liberating. You get to tailor your life to your exact preferences, right?

But here’s the catch: The human brain didn’t evolve to handle the avalanche of choices we face today.

Back in the day, “choice” meant deciding whether to hunt or gather, not choosing between 17 types of toothpaste. Our cognitive machinery gets overloaded when presented with too many variables.

This is why minimalist lifestyles are gaining traction. People are decluttering their homes, wardrobes, and even their social media feeds in search of simplicity. The fewer choices you have to make, the more mental bandwidth you free up for things that truly matter.

The Hidden Costs of Too Many Options

The tyranny of choice isn’t just a psychological concept; it has real consequences. Let’s break down some of the hidden costs:

1. Decision Fatigue

Every decision you make, no matter how small, depletes your mental energy. Think of your brain like a smartphone battery. The more decisions you’re forced to make, the faster that battery drains. By the time you’re deciding what to have for dinner, you’re too mentally exhausted to choose wisely — so you settle for fast food.

2. Fear of Regret

With more options comes the haunting possibility of making the wrong choice. This fear can make you second-guess yourself endlessly. Did you pick the best deal? Could you have done better? You may even feel preemptive regret about decisions you haven’t made yet.

3. FOMO (Fear of Missing Out)

When options are endless, the idea that you might be missing out on something better becomes all-consuming. This isn’t just about social media envy. It’s about a pervasive sense that every choice forecloses another, potentially better one.

4. Reduced Satisfaction

Oddly enough, even when you make a good choice, too many options can rob you of satisfaction. Why? Because your mind fixates on the alternatives. Instead of enjoying what you have, you’re left wondering what you’re missing.

How to Break Free from the Tyranny of Choice

So, what can you do? How do you regain control over your life when the world bombards you with choices at every turn? Here are some practical strategies:

1. Simplify Your Options

The fewer choices you have, the easier it is to decide. This is why Mark Zuckerberg famously wore the same gray T-shirt every day and Steve Jobs wore the same black turtleneck and blue jeans. It eliminates unnecessary decision-making.

2. Embrace Good Enough

Stop chasing perfection. The idea that you need to make the "best" choice is a trap. Sometimes, "good enough" is more than enough. Pick the option that meets your needs and move on.

3. Limit Your Choices

When faced with an overwhelming number of options, impose a limit. For example:

• When shopping online, filter by your top criteria.

• When dining out, pick from the first three appealing items on the menu.

• When watching TV, choose a show within five minutes or opt for a random selection.

4. Trust Your Intuition

Sometimes, your gut knows best. Overthinking can lead to paralysis. If an option feels right, trust yourself and commit.

Which choices in your life feel the most paralyzing? How will you reclaim control? Let’s talk about it in the comments.

Honest Contrarian is a space for thinkers who dare to defy the ordinary, challenge conventional wisdom, and spark bold conversations to rethink deeply held beliefs.

Share this newsletter with someone who needs a reminder.